2003
Matt Murray, 1st team pitcher
Jake Zahn, 1st team infielder
Scott Talbert, 1st team designated hitter
Sam Basta, 2nd team pitcher, 2nd team outfielder
Spencer Thompson, 2nd team infielder
Pat Steffee, honorable mention pitcher
Jon Hemmann, honorable mention infielder
2004
Sam Basta, 1st team pitcher, 1st team outfielder, conference co-player of the year
Pat Steffee, 2nd team pitcher
Chris Nash, 2nd team infielder
Drew Chandler, 2nd team infielder
Myles Midgley, 2nd team outfielder
Dave Irwin, honorable mention pitcher
2005
Ryan Krull, 1st team pitcher, honorable mention outfielder
Chris Nash, 1st team infielder, conference player of the year
Jon Hunt, 2nd team outfielder
Jeff Dean, honorable mention pitcher
2006
Tim Statz, 1st team pitcher, 2nd team outfielder
Andy Meier, honorable mention outfielder
Zac Helton, 2nd team infielder
Jon Roth, honorable mention infielder
Chad McCann, 2nd team pitcher
2008
Matt Warrick, 1st team pitcher
Kyle Grieshaber, 1st team designated hitter
Mike Corbeil, 1st team infielder
Ryan Abernathy, 1st team outfielder
Brian Bartell, 2nd team infielder
David Abraham, honorable mention catcher
Mike Dean, honorable mention pitcher
2009
Ryan Abernathy, 1st team outfielder
Mike Corbeil, 1st team infielder
Kyle Grieshaber, 1st team infielder
David Ullrich, 1st team designated hitter
Trace Gotsis, 2nd team outfielder
Matt Meyer, 2nd team pitcher
Dustin Graves, 2nd team pitcher
Nick Peterson, honorable mention infielder
Erik Enchelmaier, honorable mention infielder
2010
Matt Meyer, 1st team pitcher
Erik Enchelmaier, 2nd team infielder
Matt Seevers, 2nd team outfielder
Jake Holtzman, 2nd team outfielder
James Kramer, 2nd team catcher
Dustin Graves, honorable mention pitcher
Andy Bartlett, honorable mention pitcher
2011
Keith Grieshaber, 1st team infielder
Matt Seevers, 2nd team pitcher
Sean Ullrich, 2nd team outfielder
Danny Mannion, 2nd team utility
Andy Bartlett, honorable mention pitcher
Matt Hink, honorable mention pitcher
2012
Sean Ullrich, 1st team outfielder
Keith Grieshaber, 1st team infielder
Danny Mannion, 1st team utility player
Matt Hink, 1st team pitcher
Austin Fridley, honorable mention infielder
2013
Danny Mannion, 1st team pitcher, 1st team infielder, and Suburban West Conference Player of the Year
Matt Hink, 1st team pitcher & 2nd team infielder
Chris Lenzen, 2nd team infielder
Keith Grieshaber, 1st team infielder
Matt Scheibel, 1st team outfielder
Austin Powers, honorable mention utility player
2014
Mitch Carr, 1st team pitcher
Winston Chien, 1st team pitcher
Keith Grieshaber, 1st team IF
Jono Lazaroff, 1st team IF
Matt Scheibel, 1st team OF, Suburban West Conference Player of the Year
Dan Covert, 1st team OF
Tyler Wood, 1st team catcher
Sean McCracken, 2nd team pitcher
Charlie Kreh, 2nd team IF
Austin Powers, honorable mention utility player
Jack Matzen, honorable mention pitcher
2015
Dan Covert, 1st team OF
Brennan Barnes, 1st team P
Sean McCracken, 2nd team P
Evan Stoll, Honorable mention pitcher
2016
Will Bausinger, 1st team P
Dylan Dix, 1st team DH
Evan Stoll, 2nd team P
Ryan Potthoff, 2nd team P
Mason Mitchell, 2nd team OF
Brendan Glock, Honorable Mention OF
Turner Cook, Honorable Mention OF
Kellan Murray, Honorable Mention IF
Aaron Germeroth, Honorable Mention P
2017
Ryan Potthoff, 1st team P
Ben Kuehn, 1st team OF
Mason Mitchell, 2nd team IF
John Smalley, 2nd team P
Sam Grace, 2nd team P
Carter DeFoe, 2nd team P
Niko Porcelli, 2nd team DH
Tyler Pauley, Honorable Mention C
Jake Hansen, Honorable Mention IF
2018
Niko Porcelli, 2nd team OF
Sam Grace, Honorable Mention P
Carter DeFoe, Honorable Mention P
2019
Jake Hansen, 1st team IF
Kyle Potthoff, 1st team P
George Williams, 2nd team IF
Hunter Miller, 2nd team IF
Jack Williams, 2nd team OF
Tyler Potthoff, 2nd team P
Blake Jenkins, Honorable Mention OF
Connor Throneberry, Honorable Mention IF
Nick Orr, Honorable Mention OF
Braden Barnard, Honorable Mention P
Ian Lohse, Honorable Mention P
Tyler DeFoe, Honorable Mention P
Chewy Arnold, Sportsmanship Award
2021
Connor Throneberry, 1st team P
Mason Breidenbach, 1st team IF
Chance Woley, 2nd team OF
Zach Thelen, honorable mention P
Mason Breidenbach, Gold Glove Team
Michael Koncki, Sportsmanship Award
2022
Josh Syfert, 1st team OF
Warner Lenahan, 1st team P
Zach Thelen, 2nd team P
Sean Keegan, 2nd team DH/UT
Darion Leigh, Golden Glove Team, 1B
Max Harris, Sportsmanship Award
Carter Creech, Honorable Mention IF
2023
Rusty Graves, 1st team P
Max Cohen, 2nd team P
Alex Musel, 1st team DH/UT
Sean Keegan, 2nd team OF
Will Malsch, Sportsmanship Award
Carter Creech, Honorable Mention IF
Jack Holubowski, Honorable Mention IF
2024
2nd team IF
2nd team OF
2nd team DH/UT
Golden Glove
Sportsmanship